Peaceful Nights: The Top Foam Crib Mattresses for Infants

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Best Foam Crib Mattresses

Your baby is going to need a crib mattress of their own. While it isn’t an exciting purchase, your child will spend several years of their life sleeping in their crib, eventually transitioning to a toddler bed. Many parents like to search the selections of the best foam crib mattresses to guarantee that their baby is getting a comfortable bed.

The mattress you select is an essential item and deserves some consideration. Infants spend around 12 hours per day in their crib sleeping. That is a lot of time spent on one thing! The mattress should be safe and comfortable, ensuring they like to sleep in their crib. However, not all beds are equal and made the same. While they do need to pass certain standards to be sold in stores, you want to find a foam crib mattress that is ideal for your child.

What is a Foam Crib Mattress?

While searching for the best mattress for your infant, you will notice two different kinds: innerspring and foam crib mattresses. Instead of having coils inside of the mattress, it is comprised of polyurethane, a common form of foam. Many people love foam mattresses and find them very comfortable. They typically have an outer cover.

What to Look for in a Foam Crib Mattress

  • Firmness: Even though adults may prefer a soft bed, infants need a firm sleeping surface. Babies are unable to turn quickly on soft beds, leading to the increase of SIDS or suffocation. Pediatricians always recommend that parents purchase a firm mattress. When buying a foam mattress, you want to make sure it is dense. A firm and dense foam mattress are best for your infant.

To determine the density of the foam mattress, you should press down on the bed with your hand. When you remove it, you shouldn’t be able to see the shape of your hand. Seeing the shape of your hand indicates a mattress that isn’t firm. You want to find one that doesn’t hold the shape of your hand at all or only for a few short period.

  • Budget: Like any other purchase, you want to make sure the mattress fits into your price range. A pricey bed doesn’t automatically mean it is better than a cheaper version.
  • Heavy vs. Light: Even though a light bed seems like the better choice, you will want to look for a heavy, solid foam mattress. It shouldn’t be so heavy that lifting to remove sheets is difficult, but it should weigh more than a standard bed.

The Best Foam Crib Mattresses

Sealy Soybean Foam Core Crib Mattress

Sealy is one of the leading manufacturers of mattresses; you should feel confident using one of their products with your child. Their Soybean Foam-Core Crib Mattress meets all ASTM crib mattress standards and has the GreenGuard Gold Certification. This certification means that it meets standards for low chemical emissions, providing your infant with a safe sleeping environment.

Sealy chose soybean for their mattress because it is a hypoallergenic product. They use soy-enhanced foam on the inside of the mattress. Also, it is made with CertiPUR-US certified high-density foam that is durable enough to last for years to come. The entire mattress is wrapped in cotton for added comfort.

The bed comes with a pearl embossed, waterproof cover that will prevent leaks and stains. If there is an accident or spill, you can quickly wipe the mattress clean with soap and water. Sealy also added waterproof binding that will prevent liquids from seeping into the mattress. Also, there are airflow pockets, an important feature for an odor free bed.

Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer Dual Firmness All Foam Crib Mattress

Moonlight Slumber offers a great firm, dual-sided foam mattress. A dual-sided mattress is excellent because it is designed for both infants and toddlers. One side has an extra firm with high-density foam, perfect for babies. The opposite side has a firm, high-density foam with CertiPUR certification, softer for toddlers.

If you want a crib mattress that lacks chemicals, the Little Dreamer stands out from the other choices. This mattress has no vinyl, polyethylene, PVC, and phthalates. Little Dreamer is a top of the line mattress with the GreenGuard Gold Certification, giving off little to no emissions. The CertiPUR Foam contains no dangerous, toxic chemicals. Moonlight Slumber also uses no flame retardant chemicals.

The Little Dreamer mattress is waterproof, allowing parents to wipe the outside of the mattress with water and soap. A unique feature is the stitching. Typical beds have stitches around the top and bottom of the mattress that catches crumbs and spills. Instead, Moonlight Slumber stitches around the side, decreasing the chances of mold or bacteria growing in these areas.

Made in the USA, you can feel good about laying your baby down to sleep on the Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer mattress. It is good for the environment and your child. These are wonderfully made mattresses for a comfortable bed and nursery.

My First Mattress Premium Memory Foam Infant Crib Mattress

For families on a strict budget, some foam mattresses may be financially unattainable. No one wants their baby to sleep on a bad mattress or a rock! My First Mattress Premium Memory Foam Mattress has great features and high quality for under $100, ideal for families who need to save money.

My First Mattress is crafted with CertiPUR-US Approved foam, letting parents know this mattress is safe for children and environmental stewardship. CertiPUR Foam is made without ozone depleters, PDBES, TDCPP or TCEP flame retardants. You will find no lead, mercury or heavy metals in the foam. Your baby will sleep on a surface free of formaldehyde or phthalates. There is no reason to feel as if you can’t give your child a safe, sleeping environment because of your budget! My First Mattress gives it all to you!

It is created with extra firm high-density foam, providing plenty of support for your baby’s growing body. The mattress is hypoallergenic and offers anti-microbial protection, preventing the infestation of mites and other nasty pests that don’t belong near your child. My First Mattress measures 51.58 inches x 24.5 inches x 5 inches and fits in most cribs perfectly.

There is a removable, waterproof cover that can place into the washing machine. If your baby has an accident, you can quickly eliminate any odors or stains. For parents wanting a foam mattress, My First Mattress is one of the best foam crib mattresses you can find on the market. Parents love that it is free of toxic chemicals and the removable cover! Best of all, it is budget friendly.

Colgate Eco Classica III Dual Firmness Eco-Friendlier Crib Mattress

The Eco Classica III, manufactured in the USA by Colgate, is a top selling crib mattress. The features are great, creating a safe and comfortable sleep surface for your child. The Classica is another dual-sided mattress, giving a unique sleeping surface for infants and toddlers. Colgate marked each side, so there is no chance of confusion.

One thing to note is that the Classica III weighs around 10 pounds, lighter than other foam mattresses. Dual-sided, foam mattresses tend to weigh more, but you won’t have any issues lifting and flipping the Classica. It is six inches thick, with the perfect firmness to support your child’s growth and development.

The Classica III is eco-friendly. The cover is 100% certified organic cotton. Inside of the mattress, they added plant based foam. Many parents note that there is no smell to this mattress. It has excellent breathability that allows all scents from accidents to disappear as well. GreenGuard certifies the Classica with their Gold certification. You don’t have to worry about harmful emissions. The foam is infused with plant oils and uses safe foam.

When you purchase an Eco Classica III, Colgate offers a lifetime warranty with their mattresses. It is a great value; the dual-sided feature means you get years of use out of it, making it worth the high price. For parents who want a light, safe, comfortable foam crib mattress, Colgate makes a great selection!

Selecting your baby’s foam crib mattress is tough work! One thing to note is that all of the mattresses we selected for you are safe for the environment with little to no toxic chemicals. Selecting a safe environment for your baby is crucial. We are still unsure of the effects of sleeping surrounded by chemicals. It is wise for parents to be cautious and select a bed with few chemicals.

If you are on a budget, there is no better selection than the My First Mattress. It offers many of the same features as the higher priced mattresses. For a splurge Mattress, Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer is the best of the best. It is highly rated, receiving 5 out of 5 stars. It is, however, higher priced. The middle of the road options is the Sealy and Colgate. Both are safe, comfortable and well-crafted.

Do you have a favorite foam crib mattress for your baby? Let us know in the comments!

Leave a Comment