The Essential Guide to the Best Crib Mattress Pads

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Best Crib Mattress Pads

Parents are constantly on the hunt to make their child’s bed more comfortable.  This is because common items like pillows and blankets are not allowed in the crib.  Having too many extra items in bed with your child can pose as a health threat, so this leads parents to look for other alternatives.  Crib mattress pad are the perfect solution for all of your little one’s comfort problems.  Not only do mattress pads offer more cushion and support for your child, they can actually help to protect their mattress.  This is great news for parents on a budget because baby mattresses can run you a pretty penny.  So if you are interested in trying out one of the best crib mattress pads, stay tuned!

What is a crib mattress pad?

Crib mattress pads come in different styles and with different features but the idea behind them is the same.  They are meant to be used like a fitted sheet around your child’s mattress.  While you should never use bulky items like blankets and pillows in your child’s crib, you should always use a sheet.  This is because babies are messy, even when they are sleeping!  Between leaky diapers and spit up, chances are you will be changing these sheets a lot.

A crib mattress pad is supposed to be used between the fitted crib sheet and your child’s mattress as sort of a buffer.  However, this isn’t the only type of mattress pads out there.  Some pads are simple just pieces of foam and fabric that lie beneath the sheet.  While both styles of mattress pads serve the same purpose, the fit will be the same.  In order to find one of the best crib mattress pads for your little one, you should know what features are important for you to look for.  Here are some key things to keep an eye out for:

  • Tight fit:

If you are planning on using a fitted mattress pad, look for one that has a tight fit.  This will help to prevent the pad getting loose during the night.

  • Washable:

Most importantly, you want to find a mattress pad that is easy to clean.  Most will be machine washable which is a major plus.

  • Price point:

Depending on what type of mattress pad you want, the price will change.  This doesn’t mean, however, that you need to spend a great deal of money on one.  Most pads won’t run you more than $50 which is great news for families on a budget.

  • High quality:

The key to finding one of the best crib mattress pads is finding one that is durable and high quality.  Having a high quality mattress pad can make all the difference in the world because obviously you want one that is going to last until your child is ready to move out of their crib.

  • Waterproof:

One of the best features to look for in a crib mattress pad is if the pad is waterproof.  This will help to keep leaks and liquid from going into the center of your child’s mattress which could potentially lead to the growth of dangerous mold.

Now that you know what to look for in a great mattress pad, it is time do see how they stack up side by side.  Here are some of the best crib mattress pads available on the market today:

Bawum 5-Layer Soft Waterproof Fitted Crib Protective Mattress Pad Cover

First on the list of the best crib mattress pads for your little one is this adorable Bawum Waterproof Fitted Crib Protector.  While the brand name may not be familiar to you, parents have been raving about the mattress protector for years.  The best part of this product is that it is a mattress pad and a mattress protector all rolled into one.  This means that you don’t have to buy both which makes it a great money saving option for you.

The secret is in the waterproof features.  The five layer design not only offers an amazing amount of comfort, but also helps to trap moisture and push it away from the surface.  Not only are these layers waterproof and soft, they are also made from ultra high quality materials.  This means that this mattress pad is sure to hold up for years.  This mattress pad was designed specifically for those night time accidents.  This is a great tool for sleep training because your child will be kept dry and comfortable which will help them to sleep through the night.  All you need to do the next day is simply run the mattress pad through the washer and you are ready to go!

Here are some of the advantages and disadvantages to the Bawum 5-Layer Soft Waterproof Fitted Crib Mattress Pad as agreed on by other parents:


  • High quality materials
  • Ultra soft
  • Keeps child and mattress dry
  • Stays in place all night long
  • Doesn’t make any weird sounds when child moves
  • Nothing leaks through


  • Feels rubbery
  • Has weird smell before washed
  • Doesn’t fit European style crib sizes

Serta Sertapedic Crib Mattress Pad

If you are looking for a high quality crib mattress pad that is backed by a name brand you trust, you should check out the Serta Sertapedic Crib Mattress Pad.  Serta has been one of the top brands for everything sleep related.  From high quality cribs to baby beds, Serta has been delivering some of the best sleeping products for generations.  So there is no surprise that parents would jump at the chance to give the same comfort and trust to their little one.  The Serta Sertapedic Crib Mattress Pad is a popular product among the parenting community for one simple reason.  This is the innovative quilted top.

The quilted top to the mattress pad offers an amazing level of comfort which can help your little one fall asleep fast and stay asleep longer.  Not only is this mattress pad quilted for comfort, it is also waterproof.  This means that it will be moisture far away for the core of your little one’s mattress which can protect them in other ways.  Also, this mattress pad is also PVC and Phthalate free.  So not only does this mattress pad keep your child comfy, but it keeps fillers and harmful chemicals far away from your child’s skin.  You also don’t have to worry about this cover bunching up either.  This fitted mattress pad is covered in super strong elastic binders that promise a tight and secure grip to your child’s mattress each and every time.

What makes the Serta Sertapedic Crib Mattress Pad one of the best crib mattress pads available today?  Here are some things to consider:


  • High quality
  • Durable and long lasting
  • Trusted brand name
  • PVC and Phthalate free
  • Machine washable
  • Budget friendly
  • Fits perfect onto crib mattress
  • Easy to clean and install


  • Makes too much noise every time baby moves
  • Fell apart after six months

SureGuard Mattress Protector

While the SureGuard Mattress Protector does fall on the higher side of the price range, it is well worth the money.  This is because the SureGuard Mattress Protector is perfect for little ones who suffer from breathing problems, sensitive skin and allergies.  Often times when a child has breathing problems, like asthma, parents have to be very careful about each and every product they use around their child.  They need to make sure that every product is safe and breathable.  The SureGuard mattress protector is not only 100% waterproof, but it is also hypoallergenic.  This means that it is perfectly safe to use with sensitive children.  This is especially important because children are not constantly monitored while they are sleeping, so it helps to give you some peace of mind during bedtime.

This mattress pad works hard to block away dust mites and other allergens than can hurt your child.  Best of all, it also repels bacteria, mildew and mold.  Parents love the SureGuard Mattress Protector for how truly waterproof it is.  Not only does it repel liquids away, but it also helps to trap them to keep them from spreading.  While other mattress protectors have been labeled as uncomfortable or noisy, this one claims to be silent because of its 100$ cotton terry cloth surface.  Best of all, the SureGuard Mattress Protector 10-year quality guarantee which means that you could get a replacement or a refund if the product doesn’t hold up the way it claims to.

Why should you buy it?  Here are some reasons why parents chose the SureGuard Mattress Protector:


  • Ultra soft
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Repels dust mites and bacteria
  • Waterproof
  • Made from cotton terry cloth
  • 10-year quality warranty
  • Great customer service


  • Had to replace item often
  • Difficult washing instructions
  • Shrinks when washed

Sealy Stain Protection Waterproof Fitted Mattress Pas Cover Protector

Who says that the best crib mattress pads can only be used on babies?  The Seal Stain Protection Waterproof Fitted Crib Mattress Pad Cover Protector was specially designed to be used not only for infants but for toddlers as well.  This is because the high quality materials that this pad is made with are durable and strong enough to last for years.  Also, because baby cribs and toddler beds have the same sized mattresses, the pad will work perfect for both.  Parents also love this mattress protector because of the special stain and release technology.  This innovative system not only prevents staining on the mattress but also is easily washable.  This will help to keep your little one’s bed free of bacteria and mold which will help them to continue to live healthy and happy lives.

The best feature of the Sealy Stain Protection Waterproof Fitted Mattress pad is the high quality quilted mattress topper.  This mattress top lets your baby’s bed feel more like a ultra comfy bed while also keeping them safe.  This is because the mattress pad fits perfectly to the crib with the reinforced elastic sides.  This SecureStay mattress skirt wraps around for the perfect fit each and every time.  Also, you will love that this mattress cover is hypoallergenic.  You will also love that this product was voted to be America’s Most Recommended Crib Mattress and Bedding products three years in a row.

What makes the Sealy Stain Protection Waterproof Fitted Mattress Pad Cover one of the best crib mattress pads available on the market today?  Here is what other parents had to say about it:


  • Stain resistance and repellent
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Secure fit elastic edges
  • Highly recommended and award winning
  • Quilted comfort top
  • Keeps child cool


  • Feels rubbery
  • Has a weird plastic smell before washing
  • Can shrink in dryer

Gold Guard Bamboo Waterproof Mattress Pad Protector

If you are in the market for one of the best crib mattress pads that also is more natural than others, then the Gold Guard Bamboo Waterproof Mattress Pad Protector may be exactly what you need.  The secret to this mattress pad is in the materials that it was made with bamboo is a common theme among natural baby products.  This is because bamboo is not only strong, but also supper absorbent and durable.  The best thing about bamboo is that while it is naturally strong, it is also naturally soft.  This adds some spring and comfort to your child’s bed safely and naturally.  Also, parents love this mattress bad because it is ultra breathable.  This helps keep babies cool during warm nights which will also help to keep bacteria from growing.

The Gold Guard Bamboo Waterproof Mattress Pad Protector is also naturally waterproof.  This traps liquid and then repels it away from the mattress.  It doesn’t only work this way for moisture either.  It also works to repel away dirt and grime. So not only is this mattress pad protector breathable and safe, it also keeps your child’s sleeping situation clean.  This mattress pad is also machine washable and easy to install.  The elastic around the corners is strong enough to hold tight to the mattress while also being flexible and soft enough to move with your child.  The number one reason why parents love the Gold Guard Mattress Protector is the money back guarantee.  This brand believes in its product so much that they are willing to put their money where their mouth is.  This allows you to make a completely risk free purchase.

Why do parents love the high quality Gold Guard Organic Crib Fitted Mattress Pad Protector so much?  Here are some reasons why you should consider it:


  • Organic bamboo and cotton
  • High quality and strong
  • Money back guarantee
  • Waterproof
  • Super comfortable
  • Keeps your child’s bed clean
  • Keeps dirt and liquid away from the mattress


  • A little bit pricey
  • Can shrink when not washed properly

Nursery Necessities Waterproof Fitted Crib Mattress Cover

Looking to try the number one crib mattress pad?  Then look no further than the Nursery Necessities Waterproof Fitted Crib Mattress Cover.  This cover has been constantly voted the number one baby product by both parents and medical professionals alike.  This mattress cover claims to be better than anything else available on the market today.  This includes bamboo and cotton as well!  So what makes this crib mattress pad so special?  It is made with microfibers that link together to form one comfortable and strong mattress cover.  Not only is this fabric extremely soft to the touch, but it can actually help keep your child asleep during those long warm nights.

Not only does it keep your child cool, but depending on the weather it will keep your child warm.  This helps to make the Nursery Necessities Waterproof Fitted Crib Mattress Cover one of the best crib mattress pads available today.  You know that this cover is built to last too because the fibers are so finely woven together.  This also allows the cover to be breathable while also pushing moisture away which can help children with sensitive skin.  Many times children have skin problems, like eczema because of the dampness of their mattresses.   Lastly, you will love that this product comes with a risk free guarantee. 

Is this is the right one for you?  Here are some reasons to consider the Nursery Necessities Waterproof Fitted Crib Mattress Cover:


  • Waterproof
  • High quality microfibers
  • Breathable and comfortable
  • Easy to clean
  • Repels moisture
  • Risk free guarantee
  • Safe for sensitive babies


  • Too small to fit standard sized cribs
  • Fabric was very thin
  • Feels like sleeping on plastic

Red Nomad Crib Pad Mattress Protector

The Red Nomad Crib Pad Mattress Protector is a great option if you are looking for one of the best crib mattress pads that help with unwanted odors.  This mattress pad actually works to absorb moisture which can cause odors and then the mattress pad neutralizes them.  No more moisture and odor, no more problems!  Best of all, this mattress protector also protects your child in another way most other mattress protectors don’t.  This product actually works to keep harmful insects like dust mites and bed bugs away from your child.  This is perfect for families who live in cities where bed bugs are a growing problem and concern. 

The number one problem that most parents have with mattress protectors is how noisy they can be.  This is because in order to have a waterproof protection, there needs to be done sort of filler.  Most mattress protectors use plastics or fillers to achieve this.  While the mattress will remain waterproof, this does mean that there can be a great deal of noise when your child moves.  This is can be completely counterproductive when trying to sleep train a baby.  Even the slightest noise may be enough to disturb their sleep.  You don’t have to worry about this with the Red Nomad Crib Pad Mattress Protector.  This mattress pad keeps your child completely dry and cool without making a peep.  The secret is in the ultra soft bamboo fabric that was specially made for these little ones.

What makes this mattress protector one of the best crib mattress pads?  Here are some reasons to buy it:


  • Ultra strong bamboo
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Waterproof
  • No plastics
  • Very quiet
  • Budget friendly
  • Shields babies from insects


  • Seems way too thin
  • Has a weird smell
  • Shrinks in the wash

Wrapping it up!

Finding one of the best crib mattress pads for your little one all comes down to a personal choice.  While most mattress protectors do the same job, there is one big difference between most of them.  This is all about the materials that they are made with.  If you want a strong and long lasting mattress pad and are not concerned about allergies, go with a traditional cotton mattress cover.  These covers offer amazing comfort and style while still keeping your child warm.

If you want a more natural crib mattress cover, try to look for one that is made from bamboo.  While not all of the bamboo mattress covers are 100% organic, they do the job just perfectly.  Bamboo is strong, durable and soft which is perfect for your little one’s bed.  Just beware, if you want to get an organic mattress cover, you will have to pay for it.  Most crib fitters run less than $20 but a high quality and organic one could run you all the way up to $50.  So see what works in your budget first before hitting up the stores.  Once you have one of the best crib mattress pads you will see how quickly and comfortable your child falls asleep.  This will also help you to sleep better knowing that your child is being protected from moisture and dust.  Take care.

Leave a Comment